This is an automated archive made by the Lemmit Bot.
The original was posted on /r/tifu by /u/CluelessCombination on 2023-08-12 00:54:08.
Looong time lurker and I finally have a TIFU worth sharing.
I live in an apartment in a college town and have been working reception/cleaning for the apartment's front desk and gym part-time over the summer while school is out. For the past month or so, a really cute and nice girl has been coming to the gym towards the end of my shift a few days a week. The catch is that I know she doesn't live here; I see her car pull in and out of the complex when she comes every time.
It's not an issue to me and in fact is fairly common, we don't check for residency and the gym is well stocked so naturally people outside want to take advantage. I let in everyone because it's not crowded during the summer and it's never been a problem.
She and I make brief conversation every time she comes in, and since she comes at the end of my shift, I'm also cleaning the equipment when she's finishing up, so we've gotten to know each other. It's honestly been really nice to talk to someone casually at the end of a long shift. I've hesitated on asking her to hang out outside of this setting because I'd rather not bother someone during their workout, but we joke around and it certainly felt pretty flirty at times.
The big FU happened when we were talking at the end of her workout about how nice the gym was and she made a comment about how "it's a wonder more people don't take advantage of it". I totally thought she was being sarcastic and hinting at how she didn't live here, so to play into the joke I said something along the lines of "you're kidding, but you should've seen the last guy who tried to break in, the police were on him before he lifted the bar off his chest". Granted, not my best work, but she went pretty silent after that and kinda shrank in on herself before leaving without the usual goodbye.
I was so confident that she was in on the joke that I didn't correct myself. She's even brought in a little keychain gift for me before, which I took as a genuine thank you for letting her in. It never occurred to me that she might've taken me seriously until it was too late.
It's been about two weeks and she hasn't been back. So at the very least I lost someone to talk to at a boring ass job and at worst I threw away a chance I had with someone I was starting to like a lot by making a dumb joke that wasn't even really that funny.
TL;DR: I work reception for an apartment gym and have been talking casually to a cute girl who comes in to work out. She doesn't live in the apartment. I thought she knew that I knew said fact, so I joked about it, saying she'd be punished for taking advantage of the service. She hasn't been back since.