This is an automated archive.
The original was posted on /r/privacy by /u/br0kenpixel_ on 2023-08-23 19:54:37+00:00.
Hello!
I’ve recently been looking for a good cross-platform cloud storage solution to store my backups and documents.
My main requirements are:
- Cross-platform compatibility (Windows, macOS, Linux, Android and iOS)
- Client-side encryption
- Possibility to access using rclone (preferred since I need to use it on my NAS), or an official CLI tool
There are a bunch of providers that meet the first two, the problematic one is the third.
Why not use rclone crypt with XYZ?
I don’t want to use rclone’s crypt remote, because it would make it impossible to access my data using my iPad or iPhone, since rclone is not available on those platforms. I know there’s CryptCloudViewer, but it hasn’t been updated for a few years now and it often crashes (and it doesn’t integrate with the Files app.)
Why not NextCloud with E2EE?
AFAIK, NextCloud uses server-side encryption and apparently it’s not perfect and I also noticed some performance and other issues when this encryption was enabled (for example some apps wouldn’t install or work).
Why not use SeaFile?
Regarding performance, it does seem to perform a lot better than NextCloud… well as long as the server is set up correctly. I found a decent hosting service but I had a bunch of issues when uploading using rclone. (I’m not going to explain the details, as this post is probably long enough already.) I also tied a self-hosted instance, but I also ran into a bunch of issues when using it with rclone. Also, their CLI tool is not available for aarch64, so it wouldn’t work on my NAS.
Why not use Cryptomator?
It’s performance is terrible on macOS (with the official app) and Cyberduck/Mountain Duck don’t make it any better. I noticed that Cryptomator is written in Java, which probably explains the performance. And their Android app lacks basic features like directory uploads (for which there’s and open issue on GitHub since 2017 so I don’t see them implementing this anytime soon.)
Are there any alternatives to rclone and Cryptomator? Or is there another provider I may not know about? I’ve looked at many like Mega, Sync.com, Tresorit, etc. But they either don’t support rclone or their pricing is too high. Mega seemed OK, but I’ve read a few reviews about their encryption implementation and it doesn’t seem to be the best. Also, rclone’s Mega backend doesn’t perform that well.