Malaysia is not politically neutral, FYI, but for this use-case it's likely fine. Why not go for providers in the EU?
this post was submitted on 15 Dec 2023
11 points (86.7% liked)
Monero
1677 readers
34 users here now
This is the lemmy community of Monero (XMR), a secure, private, untraceable currency that is open-source and freely available to all.
Wallets
Android (Cake Wallet) / (Monero.com)
iOS (Cake Wallet) / (Monero.com)
Instance tags for discoverability:
Monero, XMR, crypto, cryptocurrency
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
I wouldn't use a server in the EU in general. Maybe in a specific country like Sweden with strong protections, the EU isn't politically neutral either and is doing everything in it's power to erode the privacy rights of Europeans.
The point was the equation between cost and privacy. Considering that you shouldn't really trust any provider and should be utilising as much of encryption as possible, this doesn't look to be much of a reason
The EU has:
- Moved faster than the US towards CBDC tyranny
- Digital Services Act which has privacy and censorship concerns
- Politicization of Certificate Authorities (Cas)
- France banned non-EU VPNs, although it’s not really enforced yet, it’s chilling effect
- France jailed people just for using Tor / Tails
In contrast Shinjiru has a good track record on censorship. If you look them up, the only criticism I found is someone complaining they would NOT take down someone else doing copyright infringement. While of course, I can not endorse breaking the law, I do support free speech.
Of course, EU is no haven for free speech. No doubt about it. My point was simply that EU servers might have better prices. Of course, if you don't care about that, Asia might potentially be a better idea (not Japan or Korea though).
I didn't know France sent people to jail for using Tails, that's insane. However, from the POV of a network, how would they even find the person? Unless they happen to operate a significant portion of the TOR network/NSA gave them some juicy exploits
Asia might potentially be a better idea (not Japan or Korea though)
You mean, like Hong Kong, or India, maybe? What do you mean by “not Japan or Korea though”? I’d feel China would be worse. Privacy-focused services tend to be pricey anyway, both in Europe and in the US, and the price comparison is tricky as EUR/USD can move weirdly. If you’re talking about Njalla (Sweden), it’s indeed rather expensive.
Although France seems to be generally anti-cryptography, of course you wouldn’t go to jail just because you use Tails. There was this notorious incident related to French activists & Proton, though. Also, the Netherlands can be scary. They arrested a developer of Tornado Cash, right? Although, those things have nothing to do with VPS!
It’s true that the EU is getting “difficult”. Ironically, the US (without GDPR) can be better, where the right to anonymous speech is more or less protected (although, of course, US hosting companies in general are not good for that).
IncogNet is a good example, where you can get a domain anonymously, just like from Njalla but the price being much affordable. Not only that, they’ll set up an onion/I2P version for your website for free. (This is not a recommendation, though. DYOR.)
Floki was once famous but, yeah… they’re getting a bit less popular now after the Covid things. It’s not Iceland and Seychelles based; basically it’s a German company, having servers in Iceland, Finland, Romania, and the Netherlands. Iceland was once very popular, but anymore. Using a .is domain now assuming it’s “safer” is a bit yesterday.
Especially, be aware of France: they’re like “you use encryption because you have something to hide, doing something bad.” Also, you might want to avoid EU domains (.fr etc.) in general: check about NIS2, so called “Thick Whois“ to see what this means. For example, you can’t get a .nl anonymous domain anymore (a recent change); a similar trend being expected soon in other EU registrars/resellers i.e. “domain KYC”.
PS: Incognet is based on Fran's (Frantech/BuyVM) in Canada, which has been generally trusted and has some good track record. One might want to consider BuyVM etc. too (Not a recommendation, DYOR).
PPS: Incognet accepts xmr, but you can’t do crypto-related things like mining on their servers. A negative point for some of us.
Why not go for providers in the EU?
You can go to prison for criticizing some people in the EU, it is the farthest thing from politically neutral.
Some people such as?
Politically protected groups.
Name some names. You scared or something? I can assure you I'm no Stasi agent or anything like that :p
This server and its admin is located in a nasty communist zone that persecutes people for their speech, it is called care and respect.
Use a real search engine to find out what those groups are if you are ignorant.
Are you not allowed to criticize the European Commission and Parliament in the EU? Seems like they're having trouble enforcing that given the amount of criticism of them that happens in the open across the continent. Unless you mean some other group?
You are not allowed to criticize politically protected groups not politicians. Politicians are just punching bags put out by the ruling class to absorb the public's abuse and anger.
People are getting brutalized by the state's low intelligence enforcers if they dare criticize these groups.
Like I already said, use a real search engine to find out who those groups are.
If you're on Monero or privacy instances and acting in good faith, you would not be so combative and express a genuine wish to learn.
But if you really want us to believe you can't see it with your own senses at this point then I'm leaning toward you simply acting in bad faith here and not worth wasting the time on. Seems like a troll.