this post was submitted on 08 Oct 2024
676 points (95.9% liked)
Political Memes
5453 readers
2728 users here now
Welcome to politcal memes!
These are our rules:
Be civil
Jokes are okay, but don’t intentionally harass or disturb any member of our community. Sexism, racism and bigotry are not allowed. Good faith argumentation only. No posts discouraging people to vote or shaming people for voting.
No misinformation
Don’t post any intentional misinformation. When asked by mods, provide sources for any claims you make.
Posts should be memes
Random pictures do not qualify as memes. Relevance to politics is required.
No bots, spam or self-promotion
Follow instance rules, ask for your bot to be allowed on this community.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
No, in theory libertarians are pro-choice, pro-LGBT, pro-drugs, pro-open borders.
Not saying that American Libertarians believe those things, but libertarianism specifically supports things that are non-conservative social issues.
What about in practice?
They are Republicans.
Outside of the US, yes, there are real libertarians.
American Libertarian policies from that article:
Conservatives have over the last couple years taken to labeling themselves as Libertarian to avoid the stigma of being Republican, but have never actually voted for a libertarian.
The problem being that they're also fully in favour of allowing businesses to do whatever the fuck they want. Even an ideologically "pure" libertarian would support your right to gay marriage while also supporting the right of your landlord to kick you out onto the street for being gay. They'll support legalization of all drugs, but also support your workplace being allowed to fire you for posting about weed on your social media.
Paying lip service to socially progressive ideas is meaningless if you also want to institute a neofeudalist society where every freedom is only really afforded to the wealthy.
Yes, totally agree. I’m just answering the question on how they differ from conservatives.
Full disclosure, let's not pretend that Libertarians are any good, even if they are in favor of some good things.
If the company can simply ignore a union, then the union has zero power...
Nah, the power in a union is all about denying labor. A strike is the power of the people, not the legal framework which facilitates the talks.
Then the union members can strike until the company stops ignoring them.
Strike in multiple senses of the word
The "fuck my shit up fam" of political ideologies.
They've(Republicans) taken to calling themselves libertarian(Right libertarians) yes. But they've also managed to infiltrate and take a significant chunk of power from the libertarian party.
Depends on.
At best you get people like Pipkin Pippa, who's actually way more progressive than your average conservative, but has the same flaws as other similar people, such as
(I really hope it'll only poorly age in a positive way)
Then you have people like Áron Ecsenyi, leader of the Hungarian Le Az Adók 75%-ával Párt (Down with the 75% of the taxes party), whose only libertarian view is whining about taxes and techbro stuff (he had an EV project that went nowhere), otherwise he is a bitter incel, really likes the censorship laws of Fidesz (especially the "child" protection law, as he likes to whine about gays in media), and his party is likely just there to test the waters for Fidesz whenever selling the healthcare to friends and family. Yeah, he also thinks the abysmally low age of consent of Hungary is somehow too high.
Then you have various actual nazis, like Richard Spencer, Hans Christian Graebener, etc., who don't even believe in free speech anymore.
Those "classically libertarian" values are referred to as "liberal" values today
Classical libertarians (like from the early 20th century) would be considered anarchists in today’s parlance (specifically anarcho-communists or anarcho-syndicalists)
I'm aware, I was referring to the values they listed specifically in their comment
ah yes my "classically libertarian" brothers vote red up and down ballot. they claim to have those values so they don't get the hose when they visit
I think you misunderstood me? My point wasn't that libertarians have those values, because they clearly don't. Modern Liberals have those values.
That's good, because actual "right wing libertarians" are just liberals that want to feel special.
Lol so wrong.
I'd care about your opinion on the matter if you could define liberalism.
I'm more curious in your definition actually.
Generally, from what I've gleaned, if a left wing person is using Liberal in a derogatory way, then they are referencing ideologies that prioritize personal liberties and property over greater good. A liberal in that sense wouldn't necessarily like socialist or communist policies that may have more taxes, regulations, or limitations to their personal life. I'm not claiming to be an expert, mind you.
The example I can think of (as I understand it), is say let's use single payer Healthcare. Government takes over, taxes people more, and limits the options and choices of doctors. While in general a greater good, some people who prefer personal freedoms may be upset something that used to be covered or a personal doctor they liked doesn't work under the new setup (like certain homeopathic or chiropractic not being covered as real medicine).
A liberal in this case may value their personal choices as more important. NIMBYs also count; like those who don't want low income housing near their own homes. They may claim to want to support the poor and homeless, but object if it affects their housing values or makes them uncomfortable.
I'm not sure on this next, but I'll add it anyway. The US in particular but other "liberal" countries as well have a history of exploiting weaker/less developed countries for our own comfort. Sure we all say we hate banana Republics and what the US did for those to work, but how many of us would willingly give up comforts we gain from that exploitation?
Sure bud.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberalism
Huh, that's weird. All of those values are the ones "libertarians" also claim to hold!
It's almost like "libertarians" are a kind of liberal to people who know what the word means, instead of having a vague understanding that it means "Democrat"
It's weird huh? You don't really see any Libertarians protesting police violence. Or very many up in arms when the Supreme Court said that the President is above the law. I also don't recall seeing any headlines about massive Libertarian protests when conservatives threw out decades of established law that a woman had the right to make decisions about her own body. And come to think of it, when Trump said he was going to revoke legal immigration statuses and do mass deportations, the Libertarians were pretty quiet about that too.
It's almost like Libertarians actually like a government that treads all over them, and the Don't Step on Snek flag is only about guns.