Rules:
Be civil. Disagreements happen, that does not give you the right to personally insult each other.
No racism or bigotry.
Posts from sources that aren't known to be incredibly biased for either side of the spectrum are preferred. If this is not an option, you may post from whatever source you have as long as it is relevant to this community.
Post titles should be the same as the article title.
No spam, self-promotion, or trolling.
Instance-wide rules always apply.
As an Arabic speaker, I can't find the part where it says "kill as many people as possible". Also the watermark (that's a guy's name) is interesting to say the least.
Edit: Apparently it's there nvm. Anyway while I could buy this being a Hamas document there definitely needs to be confirmation, especially with that silly-ass watermark.
Page 4 line 4, and yes this is total bullshit.
Oh you're right nvm.
Nasty bastards.
Dubious. "We found these plans on their bodies."
Maybe, maybe not.
Clearly a very controversial comment I'm replying to here but I say it has the right idea. Whenever you see a claim consider the source of the claim before you import it and its implications wholesale into your world-view. If only people practiced this attitude more.
You should see why this is important no matter if you lean pro-Israel or pro-Palestinian. On a subreddit that I won't name, a highly-upvoted response to one of the atrocious images that emerged of the attack aftermath went: "that image is fake, there was a twitter community response to it saying so". A twitter community response! That's settled then! If your credulity for believing things is a function of how much you want to believe those things, you will only become stupider with time.
I know enough to condemn Hamas purely based on facts that are not in dispute. All those festival-goers are not somehow secretly active IDF combatants. They are not somehow magically alive. Israel did not fabricate the dead babies.
Disinformation ?
They printed that and show off to the rest of the world ?
Who to trust today ?
We plebs are to easily manipulated
Btw since israel creation they continued to kill peiples ans take theirs territory.
No brainer that part
Ah yes. "So the music festival was real but a school? Naw"
How is it disinformation if it's proven that they did in fact attack schools and civilians?
Hmmm... maybe I should trust a rando on the Internet instead of multiple news organizations in multiple nations.
Cause all news outlets bad.
“Media confirms it!”
sky
India today
You forgot the New York Post
Sky news has literally given Hamas representatives a platform to pretend none of this ever happened. They say that while their agents take video of themselves torturing and killing little old ladies, on the old ladies' phones, and upload the video to their facebook account for all their friends and family to see.
Why respectable journalists would give them a platform is beyond me.
So if you're saying they can't be trusted on Israel—I agree, but not in the way you're suggesting.
Where are the 40 beheaded babies?
Where are the 40 beheaded babies?
Except that has been already proven false. Times of Israel, seriously?
That's some Putin shit right there.
Wow, Hamas is following doctrine as if they'd been trained by Navy SEALs. Did someone give them the Marine Recon playbook? They followed it EXACTLY.
Step : Don't memorize anything. Carry all relevant top secret documents with you.
Step 2: Make sure you don't die!! You're going into enemy territory with top secret documents!
Step 3: Make it back alive and with your documents so we can review and debrief. Those are the only copies!
Good thing this is in no way propaganda to justify genocide, just like those 40 babies being beheaded that no one has seen proof of. Slava Israeli!
I am sure everyone of them had a copy of the 6 page top secret documents.
The pages serve to remind them: to "inflict as many casualties as possible" they couldn't just tell them that, they'd have forgotten.
Somebody who thinks criminals are smart
Ah you got me there. They had the capability to plan and execute a military operation with many moving parts without being smart. Monekys with typewriters, broken clocks twice a day and all that. Probably why they died on their operation, too. Saw people with guns and started shooting, not realizing they were on the same side. Good point, upvote for you.
You don't need brains to pull a trigger...You only need a finger. Others plan.
So the people with brains just gave them the documents, and sent them to battle? Are you sure those brains aren't flawed?
Are you taking notes on a criminal fu*kin conspiracy?
No but it sounds like you've reasoned this out on an etch a sketch.
Another great point. Let's plan and draft up these top secret documents, and not train the soldier to the specifics of the operation, because we can just give him the documents to take with him. That way, while they're driving their jeeps and motorbikes and shooting rifles, they can take time in enemy territory to review the plan on the fly. Hopefully that idiot can read, though!
Part of it is likely that if they trained the soldiers in the plan beforehand, they risked leaks,
Now, we know there were leaks, and warnings to Netanyahu that he ignored, but Hamas likely didn't know that he would straight up ignore the threat.
There's also the issue of compartmentalization. Hamas operates in cells, because that makes them harder to kill in air strikes. They're spread out, partially disorganized, and try to keep communication between them to paper or in person. All to keep Israel from spying on them.
It's not a stretch to think that the foot soldiers were handed these papers half an hour before they were set to go. It's a sloppy way to run an op, but the op was mass murder and kidnapping, so I'm okay with them being less efficient than they could have been.
I don't think it overcomes reasonable doubt in this situation, especially given the widespread propaganda surrounding the narrative that hamas is killing children with no supporting evidence. My opinion is that critical thinking affords the benefit of the doubt to this not being accurate in this case.
Oh this guy again TROLL ALERT DON'T ENGAGE
You stalking me now sweetie?
They weren't all planners. You realize that some of them did the planning, right? And that some of them are not incredibly smart and can't commit multiple maps to memory and maybe want to bring one with themselves just in case?
I'm not convinced. It is more likely that Israel is trying to invent more justification for genocide. Throw all the italics around that you want, it doesn't overcome reasonable doubt.
The document is too prestine. It doesn't make a whole lot of sense for a soldier to carry that where it could be taken by an enemy. Somehow they're smart enough to carry out these coordinated attacks, but are too dumb to memorize their role for the supposedly top secret operation.