Welcome to Television
This community is for discussion of anything related to television or streaming.
Other Communities
Other Television Communities
A community for discussion of anything related to Television via broadcast or streaming.
Rules:
Be respectful and courteous to all members.
Avoid offensive or discriminatory remarks.
Avoid spamming or promoting unrelated products/services.
Avoid personal attacks or engaging in heated arguments.
Do not engage in any form of illegal activity or promote illegal content.
Please mask any and all spoilers with spoiler tags. ****
Almost every actor cast in Borderlands.
They got a funny man to play the straight man. A woman almost twice the age of Lilith in the game to play Lilith. Jack Black as Claptrap at least makes some sense, but it's not his usual energy and then they tweaked his voice so much I can't tell it's him from clips I've seen.
I don't see how all the responses aren't Anthony Mackie in altered carbon s2.
Because it doesn't matter who you cast in Altered Carbon season 2. Joel Kinnaman absolutely nailed it in season 1 and while I understand the story of why he is replaced, it just doesn't work. No one could have taken the role. Not that Mackie did the role any favors, but it was an uphill battle from day 1.
Kinnaman nailed the roll. season 2 had so many problems that I don't think it's fair to put the blame on Mackie.
I think it's more a problem with the new showrunner being bad at their job. The show in season 2 didn't know what tone to go for or how to structure scene.
They could have put someone good who pretended to understand the source.
Fucking smell the fart acting in a high concept scifi.
Other people took the role for short periods of the first season due to the whole premise of the show being body switching, and they were all competent at being Takeshi Kovach. If the second season had been as competently executed as the first season, the recast wouldn't have been a problem (but probably wouldn't have chosen Mackie unless it turned out the problem really was just the director making him act badly).
I didn't watch season two only because they cast Mackie, who is wooden and vanilla in everything. I don't understand how he's an actor.
Chevy Chase as Pierce on Community.
It's debatably a perfect casting because the charcter is a rich, arrogant, racist, sexist out of touch ass... and so is Chevy. He did excellent in the role and was hilarious more often than not. But because he is such a PoS who wasn't really acting, the cast, writers and crew all hated working with him and then he became a very clear burden on the entire show. Resulting in him being semi killed off, but kept appearing in convulated ways? It would've been better for everyone if he was recast right from the start.
I couldn't disagree more. Like you said, he's perfect casting. Chevy was always a bit if a dick, that was his character in every film he's ever been in. The problem, as you correctly pointed out, is that it wasn't an act.
As he got older his shitty behavior got worse and worse. If he could have humbled him self a bit and not been a burden I expect he would have stuck around.
I can't think of a single actor who could have played the role better.
But that still makes him the perfect casting.
Anything Mark Wahlberg is in. I've never seen him do a good performance, and I've seen him do a LOT of terrible ones. Mediocre is the best he's got. And yet, he is sure he's going to get an Oscar one day.
Anything played by Ezra Miller.
Common in Silo. The guy is only good as one-dimensional characters, nothing more than that.
Agreed. They’re supposed to be living for centuries in this silo, and every time I saw him walk on screen with his signature leather jacket I cringed. You just know somebody had to argue that he looked out of place, but he likely insisted he keep his look or not take the role at all.
I love how just about everyone below cites movies rather than TV. But theaters are dead now so what's the difference?
I have one: In the extremely mediocre Sahara (the 2005 adaptation of a Clive Cussler novel and why Clive Cussler never again allowed one of his books to be made into a movie) Steve Zahn cast as the "Burly little Italian" Al Giordino.
[off topic?]
One of the things that annoys me the most is when the heroes go into a dingy greasy spoon diner in the middle of nowhere and the waitress looks like a cover model. And then, because it costs more if the actress has lines, the heroes don't even interact with her.
That's why I don't like american tv shows as much. Mand di i love the Inbetweeners or peep show for example. When real people play real people. Not 30 year old top models play 16 year olds. And the have one fat extra to make fun of.
I always like Buffy The Vampire Slayer. They tried to play off that Alyson Hannigan was the 'plain' looking girl.
My son, who is an actor and a cinephile, complains about how movies and shows all have actors who look like actors, and don't look like real people. He often talks about "iPhone Face," where a character in a period piece like a 19th century western, looks like they know what an iPhone is.
https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0350079/
Luis Guzman is one of my favorite New York actors. Born and raised in the City, trained in the City, always played NYC locals. Maybe a cop, maybe a psycho, but always a New York City guy.
One day his agent calls him; they want him for a movie, The Count of Monte Cristo. He's flabbergasted. He plays New York, that's what he does. But he goes in and auditions and they decide they want him.
I remember seeing him and recognizing him and saying 'no way.' Then he starts acting and it's like, yeah, there were Puerto Ricans in the 1800s.
Yeah, I love him, too. He's always great.
My wife loves Asian period dramas and this is a hugely common thing that drives me nuts. It doesn't matter if you've got period clothing and scenery etc. If the "lowly common girl" has a perfect complexion, teeth, and obvious cosmetics it just breaks it.
This is one of the good things British shows have. People looks like people.
American productions don't allow for normie women; they all have to look like rock stars.
Kathy Bates went for an audition for the Sylvester Stallone movie, 'Paradise Alley.' She told Stallone she'd read the script and every single woman was described as 'beautiful.'
Another story I like. I saw "Erin Brockovich" with Julia Roberts. At one point in the movie Roberts interacts with a beautiful waitress. I rolled my eyes but at the end of the movie I checked the credits. The waitress was a cameo by the real Erin Brockovich.
It's especially gross in something like ready player one. I know it's already a shit ass movie, but in the book, i'm pretty sure the people are described as pretty normal or uglier and fatter. The love interest is supposed to be "ugly" and they casted a beautiful woman and drew a scar on her face. But not an ugly scar, because someone might not be able to jerk off to her. Or game of thrones. No one is really as ugly as they are supposed to be.
Dane DeHan in Valerean. The part was for an older Han Solo type. Dane was 35, but could still pass for a high schooler. The movie mostly now gets remembered for this miscast, and for its immensely interesting opening sequence, but the whole movie is made of action set pieces made out of sci fi insanity It should be remembered for that, and that Luc Besson is a grooming creepazoid.
Also, Timothy Chalamet. He was terrible in Dune, but I think he was most miscast as Willy Wonka. Hes always wooden, but Wonka needs to be animated! Cinema was introduced to the character with a fake fall into a back flip! Jeremy Alan White is right there!
I'd say Chalamet was even more miscast as Henry V. Henry was a hell-raising rowdy before becoming king, and as king, the kind of leader who liked getting into battle and hacking people to pieces. Barrel-shaped Kenneth Branagh was probably closer to the type than Chalamet, who's no kind of thug.
Many actors in the TV series Power is very poorly done and unbelievable. They do not fit the characters and make the entire series crap.
There was a miniseries about OJ Simpson and the trial and everything. They cast Cuba Gooding Jr as OJ Simpson. OJ Simpson has a square jaw, broad shoulders, tall athletic. CGJr is small, round, narrow, high pitched, etc. CGJr doesn't even look like he could be OJ's little brother. No idea how he got that part.
Anything involving Pat Hingle.
Going a bit off topic into movie, but he simply isn't Jim Gordon in the Batman films. Straight up. Does not fit in any way. I don't look at him and see Gordon. I see Hingle. And I don't like Hingle.
That stems morstly from his Murder She Wrote appearances, where I always find him to be the weak link in the guest cast. (To somewhat bring it back on topic).
Contrast that to i.e. J Jonah Jameson in the Tobie McGuire Spider Man movies. I was absolutely floored to see how they managed to get somebody who fit they look, attitude and mannerisms of what was pretty much a relatively low-screen-time side-character.
Actually in general I'd say the casting choices for the first two movies contributed very strongly to their success. So many of them just fit.
Only tv, or movies too? I vote mark wahlberg as sully from uncharted
You remember that abomination that was Aladdin (2019)? The actor who played Jafar wasn't even scary, and IMO Jason Mantzoukas would have nailed it and made the movie a little more tolerable to watch.