this post was submitted on 15 Apr 2024
86 points (94.8% liked)
Privacy
31263 readers
416 users here now
A place to discuss privacy and freedom in the digital world.
Privacy has become a very important issue in modern society, with companies and governments constantly abusing their power, more and more people are waking up to the importance of digital privacy.
In this community everyone is welcome to post links and discuss topics related to privacy.
Some Rules
- Posting a link to a website containing tracking isn't great, if contents of the website are behind a paywall maybe copy them into the post
- Don't promote proprietary software
- Try to keep things on topic
- If you have a question, please try searching for previous discussions, maybe it has already been answered
- Reposts are fine, but should have at least a couple of weeks in between so that the post can reach a new audience
- Be nice :)
Related communities
Chat rooms
-
[Matrix/Element]Dead
much thanks to @gary_host_laptop for the logo design :)
founded 4 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
The major one that concerns me is who is behind them. Even if we trust that their encryption is not backdoored, there is a lot of information that can be gathered just from the frequency of messages and who they are between.
If it came out that a three letter agency was running one of these networks, it would not suprise me at all.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Trojan_Shield
The only fix for that is for nobody to communicate, ever.
Exactly this. Everybody should be aware of their threat model.
The US military uses Signal for communication
Well no, but it is used for personal communication
I feel like a lot of the military probably uses Facebook messenger because of the convenience.
I imagine everyone is creating groupchats and assuming other people use Facebook just like pretty much every other job.
Secure in the milliary is actually pretty important. You don't want to accidentally leak troop deployments
Totally but people do get careless. We've seen it a few times with the war in the Ukraine. /r/VolunteersForUkraine is a good example of that.
I imagine it could be difficult stressing the importance of it to loved ones.
I mean, windows is so...
Yeah but you cant really obfuscate your message destination and timing without using onion routing, and really thats just making it more expensive to compromise and run. That said other things here do make it seem like a honeypot...
Its fully open source though, even the server. Might not be that hard to fork it and let people host their own servers.
Lots of rumors, very little evidence.
There's a lot of really bad stuff on Tor. Like, really bad; probably worse than you're imagining. Things that make the old rotten.com stuff look like a child's birthday party. If Tor was actually compromised, the people creating and uploading that stuff would be grabbed quickly. Instead, LEAs have to cooperate globally and run long-con sting operations in order to identify people in order to bust them. Most of the time, they're busting people that use Tor due to social engineering or one kind or another, and the remaining times it's because someone fucked up configuration on a site.
If everyone gets busted all at once (2022-2024 market takedowns is as close to that as it could come IMO) then everyone immediately stops using tor and starts using i2p or freenet or whatever system they may not have broken yet. That's baaahd for business, said the wolf in sheep's clothing.
Although they did run a cp site for months before shutting it down, so they're clearly not opposed to the long-game, especially if it involves national security (it does.)
Freenet was never really anonymous; there have definitely been busts from Freenet. IIRC it's distributed, but not anonymized; I haven't really done anything with it in ten years or so. i2p is probably pretty solid, but it's often very difficult to use. I've tried it, and most of the time couldn't make configurations work. Or else the eep sites I was trying to reach were offline. IDK.
I dunno; given that Tor was originally designed to be extremely difficult to track, and was designed by spooks, it's plausible that they aren't able to crack their own security. If they controlled enough of the network, they could, in theory, track individual users. But it would be extremely resource intensive, and they would already have to be targeting you.
IIRC, the case you're talking about involved social engineering to gain admin privileges, then illegally hacking computers through malicious javascript to leak their real IP. IIRC a huge number of the cases ended up getting thrown out because there was no way they could legally do what they did, and the convictions they did get were ones that they would have been able to get without the illegal hacking. That was, what, something like ten years ago? Around the time that The Silk Road got taken down? (That was taken down because the site owner used the same username both on the Silk Road and on a clearnet site; he essentially doxxed himself.)
What I'm talking about wrt tor is traffic shaping or node DoS leading to a Sybil attack. When the (state)actor has the ability to drop all packets from you to NON attacker-controlled guard nodes, and then once you're connected to a dirty guard, drop all connections to non-controlled relay and exit nodes, it's done. There's also an ongoing DoS attack that is able to make any guard/entry/relay/exit use 100% CPU making them unusable and it's been going on for months now. You can see it on the tor forums (relay-operators) and someone posted about it in more detail on the monero subreddit the other day.
Oh, yeah, I've been seeing that a lot of it has been really dragging for, like, the last year or so.
Yes, if a state-level actor is able to get control of all the nodes, then everyone is pretty much fucked. I suppose that, with enough nodes, you could make that kind of attack really, really hard. I'm also guessing that Monero transactions are taking a really long time right now to go through? I saw that the Finnish (?) gov't claimed to have 'broken' Monero, but they're not giving any technical information about their claims, and most current speculation is that they busted the guy doing other shit that they were able to trace link to Monero transactions. (I don't really keep up with Monero; last I knew, there wasn't a good wallet that didn't require downloading the whole blockchain, and my home internet is slooooooooooooow.)
It's not even a matter of gaining control of nodes, they can simply blackhole your access to good nodes so you end up with nodes controlled by them. Easy but loud, although it seems to be what's going on in a number of cases, and not many people are talking about it. Tor used to alert you to this, but now it's quietly tucked away into a log file. There are other vulnerabilities present in tor and the tor project devs don't seem particularly interested in them, with the DoS attacks requiring the community itself to step in with hacky solutions. I'm of the mind (never would have found myself saying this) that the tor project at large is compromised.
Monero is currently being hit by a (likely) black marble attack which is why it's so slow. They're basically flooding transactions (1/3 to 2/3 of all transactions able to be processed at any given time) so that the anonymity that makes monero work is severely degraded. Whether it breaks past transactions remains to be seen, but it absolutely weakens the anonymity of transactions done during (possibly shortly before and after) the attacks.