Technology

Who decides about objectivity?

In principle, you don't need anyone to decide. The facts speak for themselves.

In practice, people get the overwhelming majority of their information third-hand. So the people who decide on objective reality are the people who manage the media infrastructure that provides information of the outside world to their audience.

As audiences become more fractured and information streams more selective (particularly in political media), the different viewpoints provided by various news outlets and propaganda firms can create the illusion of multiple competing objective realities.

But lying and denial and selective reporting don't change reality. Eventually, the reporting begins to produce contradictions - images and statements that don't line up with one another, because they are so busy trying to reframe a momentary narrative or shape a shifting popular opinion. That dissonance is a big warning sign of an illusion at play.