Piracy: ꜱᴀɪʟ ᴛʜᴇ ʜɪɢʜ ꜱᴇᴀꜱ

Well paying for it is essentially leasing it, piracy is neither. So...

@ChatGPT@lemmings.world

What is your opinion on the following argument defending piracy, as in copyright infringement: "Piracy can't be stealing if paying for it isn't owning"

galaxy brain

To be completely frank, I couldn’t care less if it’s stealing or not. They should sell their shit for cheaper if their companies care so much, which I’m not sure they really do.

That's why I claim ownership of every hotel room I've ever stayed in and every car I've ever rented.

How does that work though if you rent a car? You don't own it, but still stealing if you "steal" it.

I will accept my downvotes in advance because what I'm about to say is probably against the mindset of most of the people that come here but:

Piracy is wrong.

I say that as someone that pirates. I'm not sure why people have to justify their actions. I know what I'm doing is wrong, I know I'm taking money away from these businesses that run streaming sites, that make movies, write books(this is the one I feel worst about because this is likely taking money directly from creators). But I do it anyway because I'm cheap, I can't afford it, its easier to pirate stuff, plenty of reasons. But none of them make it morally right, and none of them make it ethically right.

When we pirate things, we're pirating entertainment. Entertainment isn't a right. You don't need this stuff to survive. Plenty of entertainment is provided for free at libraries, online with free movies and books. Hell, you can go outside, grab a stick and a rock and boom! Free entertainment. Sure, there are people that pirate things like Photoshop to get ahead in their careers or to jumpstart them, I'm not talking to those people. Adobe has done research and they know those people buy their products when they become professionals. I'm talking to the people downloading a movie and somehow morally justifying it. But when it comes down to it, you are taking something that someone paid money to make in an effort to make money off of it. In my mind, there's no justification for that. Again, I don't care that you do it, I do it too. But no one is gonna get any points in my mind for stating that somehow what you are doing is right, or that it isn't stealing because you're downloading a copy of something. How silly an argument that is. If you take something that someone else expects money for and it isn't vital to your survival, that is wrong.

I'll get off my soapbox now. I love all of you, have a great day :).

So what does he think about renting cars? Lol, what a dumb take.

That's why I break into hotel rooms.

This is why I only carjack rental cars, it's totally not stealing!

I would steal this argument, but if it can be reposted here for free, then I don't think anybody really owns it. 🤔

Touché.

Amen!

Child logic to justify behavior. Be better than this ya’ll.

While I appreciate the sentiment, theft of service is a crime. You don't have to be able to own something to be able to steal it.

This💯

If a service costs money, and you take that service for free without permission it is stealing. If I rent a car I don't own it. Is it not stealing to hijack a rental car for a few hours?

You can't have your cake and eat it too. You steal because it is easier or cheaper. Thats it.

I have a better idea: Instead of piracy, just don't use/consume products that are exclusively distributed through shitty business models. At least when it comes to software, that's much more effective.