LOL, you had one job!
this post was submitted on 28 Aug 2023
118 points (98.4% liked)
Ukraine
8167 readers
408 users here now
News and discussion related to Ukraine
*Sympathy for enemy combatants in any form is prohibited.
*No content depicting extreme violence or gore.
Donate to support Ukraine's Defense
Donate to support Humanitarian Aid
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
That'll be down to the Russian response time of "whenever they can be bothered".
It is all very well detecting the drone, but if you then proceed not to do anything about it, it's not a particularly useful system.
I would love to understand how it's electronic warfare resistant. I wonder if it's just manually flown rather than GPS.
Obviously though I don't expect anyone that knows to answer. We can wait till it's in the history books.
you can still jam common control channels in this case, like with any other FPV drones
you can't jam everything, because it would consume enormous power and system would be massively complex. my bet is that they have used some band that was not commonly used, and so, not jammed yet. maybe it's a band that is normally used by some obsolete protocol or service, that got commandeered for use by military
all it takes is making FPV drone communication modules from scratch, it's custom job but also known technology. maybe even some components were already commercially available
there are much niftier techniques, but this is probably the simplest one and i don't think anything more advanced is needed in case of disposable FPV drone
Ah, okay, so it's about making sure the signal can still get through. That's not an easy problem to solve because the video and the control signals run on different frequencies and you need both of them to work.
I have more speculation about how they might've done it but I'll fight my tendency to infodump just this once.
when you're making everything from scratch anyway you can move both of them wherever you want, including next to each other
I'm pretty sure "heavily jammed" means most radio frequencies will be jammed.
But the drone can enter autonomous mode when it happens and direct itself with lidar, gyroscopes and cameras I imagine.
You can also direct it with the jamming signal itself if that's what you're looking for.
if you expect drones to be used, it makes sense to jam 2.4ghz, 5ghz (communication with drone) and 1.6 ghz (gps signal), maybe some more obscure bands like 900mhz and 3.2ghz (communication with drone) but if you make custom drone that uses, say, 7ghz frequency for communication, that's outside of normal bands and it's most likely not jammed because there's no point if it was never used. just filter everything else out and you're good to go. jamming only thin bands instead of blanketing everything makes jamming effective over much larger area with the same power. you can even make drone use some band that's used by, for example, enemy's radar that's currently not in area, so that band is not jammed by EW device but also not jammed by radar
But the drone can enter autonomous mode when it happens and direct itself with lidar, gyroscopes and cameras I imagine.
and how it's guided? as in, how it's communicated with operator? because it's happening here. laser in free space would probably require another drone with line of sight to the first one, as a repeater, and this one also needs to be not jammed, otherwise you need line of sight from drone to operator and this would be pretty hard over distances drones are used now
anti-radiation drone (like anti-radiation missile) would be pretty nice idea but this one is clearly guided manually, like every other FPV drone. it would also be much bigger (needs some 15x15cm panel with antennas as seeker at minimum and some circuitry for extracting direction from signal)
Russians are more stupid than I thought then. Jamming commercial bandwidth only is like making armours against commercial weapons only. It's plain stupid.
For communication you can command it before it get jammed. Automatic mode could either have a target already or find one alone (although this one might be risky).
If you can designate the target while the drone is controlled, then it can direct itself with its own sensors like a missile.
I’m pretty sure “heavily jammed” means most radio frequencies will be jammed.
Why arent Russians jamming everything? Are they stupid?
if you attempt to do this, you get three pretty big problems.
-
you want to jam only the enemy's frequencies. if you jam everything, you are denying yourself communications, both civilian like gsm or wifi and whatever specialized devices you might have, and more importantly you are jamming your own radars. things get trickier when you and your enemy are using the same bands, like 2.4/5ghz wifi for drone control. sometimes you don't see EW used for this exact reason
-
power spectral density drops massively, decreasing effective range of your jammer. there's no hard border between jammed/not jammed, there's a gradual transition instead. when you put lots of radiation in bands that nobody uses, you're limiting jammer for no reason. it's better to blare noise only on narrow bands where there's actual traffic. can you jam everything from 2 to 3.5ghz? sure, but if you really need to jam only 2.4ghz wifi band, then you're limiting range by about 4x or so, everything else being equal. additionally, things get broadband and it's bad, because all components need to be broadband, which is harder, heavier, more expensive, or you need to bundle what is effectively several jammers next to each other, some of which would only jam, say, friendly radar
-
if you're jamming, you're jamming for everyone. this also means that you can't use electronic surveillance on bands that you're jamming, for example you can't locate wifi transmitters or drones if you jam wifi bands
no, "heavily jammed" does not mean "all bands are jammed" as evidenced by fpv drone being controlled by operator and receiving video output, which means that whatever bands they used were open. "heavily jammed" more likely means that common bands like 2.4ghz or gps bands had large spectral power density of whatever they used for jamming (does not have to be white noise and probably wasn't)
all the fpv drones they use are manually flown and dont have gps, but yeah it would be cool to know
They must have been pretty close, since it's manually flown like that.
i mean you can get line of sight video reception out for miles, without looking too hard theres someone who flew out 8 miles, and thats probably limited by battery so a kamikazi drone could go further.
i fly fpv drones for fun so its an odd feeling seeing them used as weapons
You can't use either the GPS or the remote controle when it's jammed.
I would imagine there is an autonomous mode working lidar, gyroscopes, and maybe cameras. Like actual missiles as far as I understand.
You would remote controle the drone, and when it lose controle, it enters autonomous mode.
I'm no military expert so take this with a grain of salt, but that's how I would imagine it.
The fact the drone exploded and we got video right up to the end suggests it's getting a signal out, otherwise there'd be nothing left to recover the video from.
Haven't seen that. But it's not jammed then.
I'm no expert but this looked human-controlled in how it went for a pass, missed, and came back for the kill. FPVs are usually lightweight so I doubt they can carry the hardware for autonomy. My guess is they are using bands that aren't jammed.
Funny to see all these anti-drone and anti-air systems being taken out by.... drones!
But that's like saying that radios are unjamable because they use different frequencies. They're not unjamable they're just harder to jam.
My guess is there's different levels of fallback, Humans can pilot it when there's a signal, if that fails it can use GPS with some kind of pre-selected target, and that fails it can use on board tracking.
However I suspect that the best anti-electronic warfare attack it has is just relying on the fact that the Russians haven't got it switched on. Like how most of the autonomous assault boats rely on the fact that the Russians never seem to actually have any guards on duty.
If they can simply switch frequency band the jamming is not really heavy and the title misleading.
We can do broadband jamming since ww2.
I mean they can't jam everything, that would leave them without communications for instance. If you figure out which frequencies the Russians are using and work within that band, you could get around the jamming.
Nice soundtrack. Ironically it was a song inspired by Glasnost, when the Soviet Union finally seemed to open up to the west and become more transparent and democratic ("Wind of Change").