this post was submitted on 18 Dec 2023
69 points (92.6% liked)
Futurology
1762 readers
276 users here now
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Why don't all electric vehicles have wind funnels built into the grill and push that wind to a onboard wind turbine to help charge batteries?
Could we not beat up OP for asking an honest question? I get it, you get it, OP does not.
Only been here a few months, but it's becoming reddit 2.0 in a hurry.
Downvoting is for trolls and other dishonest posts. Want to make this a popularity contest? Is that what we're doing here?
So, you make me sound retarded.
Are you saying it's impossible to engineer vehicles to capture wind power into a turbine to increase battery power?
Sorry, but, you'll need to explain step by step... Why vehicles can't be equipped with air capture devices that funnel wind power into a turbine that feeds that battery.
Earth has many "wind farms".
Why can't that concept be scaled down to get wind power from a vehicle?
BTW, ELI5.... because, obviously I'm too stupid to understand the details.
You can, but the energy gained from the turbine will be less than the extra energy it takes to drive the vehicle now that there is a wind turbine attached.
You proposed it in the grill, but for simplicity let's put a wind turbine on the roof. To turn the blades, the wind needs to exert a force on them, and for the blades to not fly off the back of the vehicle, the vehicle needs to match that force. So now the vehicle is working harder to move forward.
It may be easier to visualize if you think of the turbine like a parachute. Once the car is up to speed, you release the turbine out of the back attached by a string. It will spin in the wind, and twist the string, but the car will slow down.
You could put this into the grill, or some part of the vehicle and fool yourself that it's not added force, but cars are designed for wind to go around them, not for wind to push on them. So no matter how you add a turbine, it's added wind resistance.
I don't believe that a design can't be created to provide even the slightest bump in energy gain v. resistance.
If a system gets a bump in energy output vs the energy put into it you end up with a perpetual motion machine. The law of conservation of energy stops that. Add on top of that friction and vibrational losses before converting the kinetic energy to electricity you will end up causing more drag than the amount of energy generated can offset.
Sorry, I still don't believe a positive effect air capture system can't be built.
You could give this guy a watch who is actually testing this IRL and wait and see what his conclusions of this experiment will be in his next video.