He gave Sirius a slight nudge. “I’m going to do it,” James whispered to Sirius. “After the Order meeting ends, I’m going to propose to Lily.”
“Again?” Sirius raised his eyebrows at James. “You’ve really got to stop pining after Evans. Seriously, you went on one date with her back in 7th year. And it ended with her hexing you so bad you spent a week in the hospital wing."
“Come on, Sirius, you’re supposed to be on my side!” James pouted.
“I am on your side. But this is like the tenth time you’ve tried asking her to marry you.”
“Twelfth.” James corrected. “But I’ve got a good feeling about it today.”
“You said that every other time, too.” Sirius pointed out.
“You know, I could always make Remus my best man at the wedding.” James threatened.
“Uh… What I meant was… Go get 'em, champ!” Sirius thumped James on the back.
Dumbledore concluded the meeting. As everyone started shuffling out, James went up to Lily, pulled out his ring box, and got down on one knee. The other Order members barely spared James a glance, as his proposals have become something of a regular occurrence.
“Lily Evans, will you marry me?” James asked, hopefully.
Lily just looked down at him disdainfully. After a long moment of thought, she answered him curtly. “Alright, fine.”
James was frozen in shock, having not expected her to say yes. Lily picked up the ring and put it on, turning her hand and observing how it looked on her finger.
James stayed kneeling on the ground, staring in disbelief at the ring on Lily’s finger. Eventually, Lily looked back down at him. “Well? Are you going to stay down there all day?”
James hurriedly got up. “Sorry, I just- I wasn’t expecting… Umm…” he trailed off.
James awkwardly tried to lean in for a kiss, but Lily held out her hand. “Not so fast, Potter. Don’t expect me to suddenly fall in love with you just because we’re engaged.”
“Huh? But then why did you say yes?”
Lily scowled at James. “Were you even paying attention in the Order meeting?”
“Uh…” James said eloquently. He hadn’t really listened much, too busy stealing glances at Lily. “Something about a Prophecy, I think?”
“A child born in late July to those who’ve thrice defied Voldemort will be able to vanquish him.”
“Right, yeah.” James nodded.
“You and I have both fought him three times.”
James’s eyes widened. “You’re saying we should get married so that our kid can beat Voldemort?”
“I’m saying that we need to do whatever it takes to kill Voldemort. And if that means getting married and having a child, then so be it.” Lily said, glaring at him.
James’s eyes widened. He pinched himself to make sure he was awake. This situation felt like it belonged in one of his more erotic dreams. He didn’t know what to think. He loved Lily, and he wanted to marry her, but not because of some Prophecy. Eventually, he made a decision. As much as he wanted this, it didn’t feel fair to her.
“We, um, don’t have to get married if you don’t want to…” he said meekly.
Lily sighed. “Look, James, It’s not about what we want. It’s about what we have to do.”
“We don’t have to…” James mumbled.
Lily’s scowl deepened. “Do you not want to get married, then?” She asked in annoyance.
“No! I do! But I want you to marry me because you want to, not because you feel like you have to.” James told her. “This doesn’t seem fair.”
Lily scoffed. “I don’t see what you’re complaining about, you’re not the one who has to give birth.”
“You deserve a choice-”
“Choice?” Lily interrupted. “What choice? If we aren’t willing to do whatever it takes to win this war, then why are we even here?” Lily huffed in annoyance.
“We’re both here for the same reason, Lily. We both chose to fight against Voldemort.”
Lily’s eyes flashed with anger. “I didn’t choose to fight.” she hissed.
James was confused. “What are you talking about?”
“You don’t understand. You, or Sirius. You’re both purebloods, after all.”
James was even more confused. “What's our blood got to do with anything?”
“Why are you here, James?” Lily suddenly asked.
“Huh?” James asked, confused at the sudden digression.
“Why are you fighting against Voldemort?”
“Well- Because it’s the right thing to do.” he answered, as if it were obvious.
“Because it’s the right thing to do.” Lily repeated. “You want to do the right thing. And that’s all well and good, but it just proves that people like you will never understand. Not really.”
“What do you mean? What don’t we understand?”
Lily glared angrily. “Do you think I want to be here, in the Order, spending my time fighting a guerrilla war against terrorists? I’m not here because it’s the right thing to do, or some other idealistic nonsense. I’m doing this because I have to. I’m here because there are people who would see me dead for the great crime of not having been born to the right parents.”
“You still chose to fight, though.” James tried to argue. “Lots of Muggle-borns have fled the country.”
“Why should I leave? This is my world, too! If the Pureblood bigots don’t like it, then THEY should leave!” Lily countered. “I know that this country isn’t perfect. The Ministry is corrupt, magical creatures are oppressed, and Squibs have almost no rights at all. But despite all that, it’s still my home, and I’m not going anywhere.”
“Right, yeah.” James said, taken aback by Lily’s anger. “But you could have stayed without fighting, right? Like, staying in the Muggle world?”
“So you would have me just snap my own wand, and live out the rest of my days as a Muggle? I am a Witch! Magic is my birthright, just as much as it is yours. I refuse to bow down to the bigots. I will not reject part of who I am, just because some people don’t like the idea of me having magic.”
“C’mon, Lily, you know that’s not what I meant. You’re not being fair.”
“Oh, grow up! This isn’t a game. I’m not some spoiled rich kid playing the hero. I’m not a noble scion rebelling against my family. You and Black, you're two of a kind, sentimental children forever whining about how bitterly unfair your lives have been. Well it may have escaped your notice, Potter, but life isn't fair! Do I want to marry you? No. Do I want you to get me pregnant? No! Do I want to give birth? NO! But I will. I’ll do all of those things, if it’ll help end this war. Not because it’s the right thing to do, but because it is my duty to either take down Voldemort, or die trying.”
Lily grabbed James by the arm and started dragging him out of the meeting room. James, reeling from Lily’s tirade, simply let himself be dragged off. “W- Where are we going?” he asked.
Lily grit her teeth. “Do I really need to spell it out for you, Potter?”
“Spell what out for me?”
“The prophesied child will be born at the end of July.”
“...Okay?” James said slowly, wondering where Lily was going with this.
“And it’s late October now.” Lily explained.
“What’s that got to do with anything?”
Lily rolled her eyes. “Don’t you get it, Potter? The end of July is nine months away.”
James’s jaw dropped. “What- Are you saying that we should…?”
“Have sex, yes.”
James was blushing furiously, and Lily sighed. “Oh, please tell me I don’t have to give you ‘The Talk’.” she said in exasperation.
“I know how it works.” James replied, embarrassedly.
“Thank Merlin.” Lily muttered, mostly to herself.
“So you’re, um, sure about this?” James asked, stunned, as he continued to let himself get dragged along.
“Why are you complaining, Potter? Isn’t this what you’ve been wanting for years?”
James just nodded mutely.
“Come on, then.” Lily dragged James into a spare bedroom in the Order headquarters. She glanced around and nodded. “This should work nicely.”
“Wait… HERE? NOW?” James asked in disbelief.
“The sooner we do this, the sooner Voldemort dies.”
“Hang on, Lily.” James tried to say, as Lily closed the door behind them.
Lily turned to give James a raised eyebrow. “What is it? You don’t want to have sex with me?”
“I do! It’s just-” James paused for a moment to organize his thoughts. “I want to, yes, but I never imagined our first time together would be like this.”
“And I never imagined ever having a first time with you, Potter, but here we are.”
“I just pictured something a bit more romantic.”
Lily rolled her eyes and flicked her wand. The blinds drew themselves closed, and several candles around the room lit themselves. “There. Nice and romantic. Now let’s get started.”
Lily started unbuttoning her shirt, and James couldn’t help but let his eyes linger on her newly exposed skin. “You’re absolutely sure about this?” he asked again.
“The Muggles have a saying, James: ‘Lie back and think of England’. You should keep that in mind.”
“Um… Shouldn’t you be the one keeping that in mind?” James ventured.
Lily snorted. “Ha. That’s a good one, Potter.”
“Huh?”
Lily roughly shoved James backwards onto the bed, and then climbed on top of him. She leaned in close to whisper into his ear. “Now, just be a good boy, lie back, and think of England.”