This is an automated archive.
The original was posted on /r/datahoarder by /u/Maora234 on 2023-08-15 07:01:00+00:00.
Hello, one and all.
As the title suggests, I am looking for advice on what hardware to get for the Silverstone DS380B case. The reason why I'm looking for advice is due to the fact that, unlike full-size computer towers that are spacious, I don't have much experience regarding the preferred hardware for the small form factor cases.
From what I read, the case requires a HBA card, so I bought the LSI 9240-8i kit from Server Labs (though I don't know how it's different to the Dell model they have listed). But that is all I have bought in terms of hardware for the case.
Use Case:
I plan to use the NAS as a backup system and as a file server for the most part. I also intend on using all 12 bays for hard drives, although cooling might be an issue (from what I read). Though it will also host media files, I don't know if it's better to host / run the Plex Media Server (for example) through the NAS System itself or have a separate computer system to host / run Plex Media Server and connect it to a shared directory for the media.
The reason why I'm entertaining the 2nd option is due to the fact that the quality of the media are not in 4K or remuxed and is in 1080p or lower, and I have a Dell Optiplex with a small form factor video card installed that might be suitable for the job.
I also plan on having the backup and files in one dedicated pool and the media in another, as a way to keep things separate. Like the important stuff in one and not as important in another.
Deciding on the Operating System:
As for the operating system, I am having trouble with what to use between OpenMediaVault, XigmaNAS, and UnRAID. Although I am leaning towards UnRAID, what troubles me is that I've seen a number of users experiencing some sort of data corruption or loss, which I would like to avoid if possible.
Regarding budget:
I happen to live in Australia living on disability, and from what I noticed, the prices for computer and server hardware are usually fairly high, and the deals for hard drives doesn't happen all too often, and when they do happen, the discounts / savings are fairly small. Especially when it's compared to the Amazon deals that are shared here on reddit.
As such, with a limited income and overall costs needed for the project, I intend on getting the hard drives after acquiring the other hardware. Once that's done, I'd first get the hard drives for the internal bays before using up the hot swappable bays.
So, with that said, what would you recommend?
I do have a couple of other questions, and I'm sure that the answers are going to be different depending on what operating system is in use. So, any answers would be deeply appreciated, whether it's for one operating system or more.
- What I am curious about is the best use for the hard drives in the internal bays?
- If I were to use UnRAID as the operating system, would using two hard drives for cache and the other two for parity (or a similar setup) be acceptable?
To those who read the post and / replied, thank you in advance.